☎ (928) 242-3192· Serving the White Mountains since 2015Equal Housing OpportunityShawn Wirtz
Shawn J. WirtzREALTOR® · BETTER CALL SHAWN
Heber-Overgaard Real Estate & Homes for Sale
Heber-Overgaard · White Mountains, AZ

Heber-Overgaard Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Heber-Overgaard is a quiet pair of Rim-country towns along Highway 260, in the pines at about 6,600 feet on the edge of the Mogollon Rim. Buyers come here for a cabin in the pines within easy reach of the Valley. I help buyers and sellers across Heber and Overgaard (ZIP codes 85928 and 85933), from cabins to acreage.

LIVE MLS LISTINGS

Heber-Overgaard Cabins & Homes: On the Market Now

Updated straight from the MLS. Tap any listing for photos, details and showings.

Search Every White Mountains Listing →

Search Heber-Overgaard Homes for Sale

Current MLS listings in Heber-Overgaard are shown above and update automatically. Search every Heber-Overgaard listing on the map → Prefer a hand-picked list? Get my tailored list →

About Heber-Overgaard

Heber and Overgaard sit side by side, surrounded by the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest along the Rim. The pace is relaxed. Some owners come up for weekends, and others live here full time.

You will find everything from rustic cabins and manufactured homes on wooded lots to newer custom builds, along with plenty of land for buyers who want to build. Because it sits right on the Rim, it is a short drive to Rim lakes and overlooks.

Things to Do & See

  • Mogollon Rim overlooks: Clifftop views that stretch for miles, minutes from town.
  • Black Canyon Lake: A quiet, pine-ringed lake popular for trout fishing and paddling.
  • Rim Lakes Recreation Area: Woods Canyon and Willow Springs Lakes and their trails are a short drive west along the Rim.
  • Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest: Miles of forest roads for hiking, hunting and off-road driving right out the back door.
  • Local shops and diners: A handful of cafes, general stores and seasonal spots along Highway 260.

Why Buyers Choose Heber-Overgaard

  • A cabin-in-the-pines setting on the Mogollon Rim
  • Easy access from the Valley along Highway 260
  • Cooler summers than the Valley and snowy winters
  • Affordable cabins, manufactured homes, and building lots
  • Surrounded by lakes, trails, and national forest

Neighborhoods & Communities in Heber-Overgaard

Heber-Overgaard is a patchwork of pine-covered subdivisions on the Mogollon Rim, from master-planned resort communities to quiet cabin tracts. A few of the areas I help buyers and sellers with:

  • Bison Ranch: the area’s best-known master-planned community, built around an Old-West-style town center with cabins and condos, a pool, trails, restaurants, and shops. It has an active HOA and amenities, which makes it popular for second homes and vacation rentals.
  • High Country Pines: a neighborhood of custom-built homes among tall ponderosas, with larger lots, mountain views, and easy access to National Forest recreation.
  • Forest Trails: a popular cabin community on roughly three-quarter-acre wooded lots, known for its log-sided cabins and quiet, tree-lined streets.
  • Mogollon Estates: a Rim-community favorite for newer cabins and build-ready lots in the pines.
  • Mogollon Airpark: a fly-in community where homes sit among the tall pines with access to a private airstrip.

Beyond these, Heber-Overgaard has many smaller tracts: Pine Meadows, Buckskin Canyon, Tennyville, and more, most with low or no HOA dues, all surrounded by the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest. If you’re still deciding on a town, I work in nearby Show Low, Forest Lakes, and Clay Springs & Pinedale.

Heber-Overgaard Land for Sale

Land is a big part of the market in both ZIP codes, Heber (85928) and Overgaard (85933), from wooded lots in cabin subdivisions to acreage near the national forest. Before you make an offer on a lot, check:

  • Water. Many lots are served by Arizona Water Company’s Overgaard system or the Heber Domestic Water Improvement District. Outside those service areas, the lot needs a well or another water source, so confirm which applies first.
  • Septic. Most lots need a septic system. In Navajo County the permit goes through Navajo County Planning & Building (928-532-6040).
  • Rules. Heber and Overgaard are unincorporated, so Navajo County zoning applies, along with any subdivision CC&Rs. Check whether they allow the home, RV or outbuilding you have in mind.
  • Clearing the lot. The Heber-Overgaard Fire District issues burn permits for slash and pine needles, and its burn line at (928) 535-6709 says whether burning is allowed that day. The district also runs a brush pit off State Route 277.

The land buying checklist covers access, water and septic in more detail, and White Mountains land for sale compares lots across the region.

Shawn’s Local Favorite

Drive out to a Rim overlook near sunset. Standing on the edge with the forest dropping away below you shows what this area is about. Black Canyon Lake is a good stop the next morning.

Market snapshot · November 2026

Heber-Overgaard home sales right now

$365,500Typical sold price
$284Typical price per sq. ft.
85Typical days to sell
152Homes sold (past 6 months)

Homes (not land) that sold, from the local MLS (the shared database agents list homes in), as of Nov 1, 2026. “Typical” is the middle number: half were higher and half were lower. Updated monthly. Not a valuation of any property.

Living here

Heber-Overgaard costs & services

CountyNavajo County
Property taxesMedian property tax paid by homeowners: $1,298 a year (median home value $271,200). A primary residence gets Arizona’s homeowner rebate on part of the primary property tax (up to $600 a parcel), so the same house as a second home or rental usually pays more. Check any parcel’s actual bill: Navajo County Treasurer property lookup.
InternetHouseholds with a broadband subscription: about 76%. Check providers and speeds for an exact address on the FCC National Broadband Map.
ElectricNavopache Electric Cooperative (Heber and Overgaard district).
Water & septicVaries by parcel: town or private water company in some areas, private or shared wells or hauled water in others, and septic outside sewer areas. See my wells, septic & utilities guide.
SchoolsHeber-Overgaard Unified School District. Boundaries can vary by address, so confirm with the district.
Nearest hospitalSummit Healthcare Regional Medical Center (Show Low), about 41 road miles
Phoenix Sky Harbor AirportAbout 135 road miles

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates (shown for communities of 1,000+ people); Census school district boundaries; electric utility service areas (Navopache Electric Cooperative and APS); road miles from OpenStreetMap routing from the town center. Checked October 2026.

Heber-Overgaard Real Estate FAQs

Are Heber and Overgaard one town or two?

They are two adjacent communities that function as one, usually written together as Heber-Overgaard. Shops, services and neighborhoods run together along Highway 260.

What ZIP codes cover Heber-Overgaard?

Heber is 85928 and Overgaard is 85933. I can search both together, so you see homes for sale in 85933 and 85928 side by side.

Is there land for sale in Heber-Overgaard?

Yes. Lots in cabin subdivisions and larger acreage near the national forest come up regularly. Check water service, septic, county zoning and any CC&Rs before you buy.

What is the elevation and weather like?

The towns sit around 6,600 feet, so summers are noticeably cooler than the desert and winters bring snow.

What kinds of properties are available?

Rustic cabins, manufactured homes on wooded lots, newer custom homes, and plenty of land for those who want to build their own place.

What lakes are nearby?

Black Canyon Lake is close, and the Rim Lakes area with Woods Canyon and Willow Springs Lakes is a short drive west along Highway 260.

What Heber-Overgaard Clients Say

Real reviews from my clients on Zillow and Google, word for word.

★★★★★
“Shawn was responsive, patient and kind. He stuck with us and didn’t get frustrated when we looked st property both on line and in person over a two year period before buying. He knows the White Mountains of Arizona and the market well and I would recommend him to anyone looking to purchase or list.”
Verified Zillow clientBought a home in Overgaard · Dec 2023 · Zillow
★★★★★
“Shawn was easy to work with and kept us fully informed at all times recommend. We walked twice from homes due to inspection. He took care of everything. Very good with all real estate issues.shawn was on top of knowing what we were looking for and never wasted our time to look at properties not meeting what we wanted and price range he helped us save 5K on a counter offer. He had great knowledge of sellers wishes and worked great with all people. We picked him off a posted house on line. Looked at reviews and were very happy.”
Verified Zillow clientBought a home in Heber · Sep 2023 · Zillow
★★★★★
“Shawn was extremely helpful and responsive. Made this selling process simple and easy. He handled everything from start to finish. Highly recommend!!”
Scott F.Sold a property · Sep 2026 · Google

Read all reviews →

Latest Local News & Guides

Recent posts from my blog on what’s changing around the White Mountains.

See all posts →

Your Heber-Overgaard Realtor: Recent Sales with Shawn Wirtz

I’m Shawn Wirtz, a REALTOR® with Advantage Realty Professionals in Lakeside. Since 2015 I’ve closed 10 sales in Heber and Overgaard (8 homes and 2 land parcels), part of 398 across the White Mountains (my closing records as of November 2026). Here are a few of them.

More Heber-Overgaard Sales

Represented by Shawn J. Wirtz · Advantage Realty Professionals

  • 2815 Pine Hill Drive Overgaard$312,500
  • 2852 Timber Trail Loop Overgaard$270,000
  • 1979 Doe Circle Heber$207,000
  • 3486 Quail Run Road Overgaard$180,000
  • 2130 Cottontail Road Overgaard$130,000
  • 2703 Rustlers Roost Overgaard$123,000
Better Call Shawn - Shawn Wirtz, White Mountains REALTOR

Thinking of selling in Heber-Overgaard?

I’ve closed 398 White Mountains property sales since 2015, including 10 in Heber and Overgaard. If you have a cabin, home or lot to sell up here, give me a call.

Advantage Realty ProfessionalsMLS and Equal Housing Opportunity