By the Numbers · November 2026
Homes for sale right now, not homes that sold. Data: White Mountain Association of REALTORS® MLS (homes for sale), as of Nov 1, 2026. Typical rent: Altos Research / Lawyers Title, as of Nov 2, 2026.
Asking prices vs. what homes sell for in Heber-Overgaard
The typical home for sale in Heber-Overgaard right now is listed about 5% higher than the typical home that sold recently. That doesn’t mean sellers are taking 5% off. Over the past year, homes in Heber-Overgaard sold for about 96% of their last asking price, after any price cuts, or about 4% under.
Why the gap? Homes that are priced right tend to sell and come off the market, while higher-priced homes often stay for sale longer. So the homes for sale at any moment lean pricier than the ones that just sold.
“Typical” means the middle price: half the homes were higher and half were lower. Sold: 152 homes sold in the past 6 months, from the local MLS (the shared database agents list homes in) via Flexmls, as of Nov 1, 2026. For sale: 138 homes listed, from White Mountain Association of REALTORS® MLS (homes for sale), as of Nov 1, 2026. The 96% figure: Flexmls Market Trends, October 2025 through September 2026. Every home is different, so ask me what a specific one is likely to sell for.
How Heber-Overgaard compares with the rest of the White Mountains
Typical sold price, price per square foot and median days to sell (sold homes) in each area, as of Nov 1, 2026. Heber-Overgaard highlighted.
Homes that sold, from the local MLS (the shared database agents list homes in). Show Low and Pinetop-Lakeside use the past 90 days, most areas the past 6 months, Clay Springs & Pinedale the past 12 months. Areas with fewer than 20 sales can swing a lot from month to month. Not a valuation of any property.
Heber-Overgaard over the last 24 months
233 homes sold in Heber-Overgaard from October 2025 through September 2026, up 9% from 214 the year before. Tap or hover any bar for its number.
Oct 2024 – Sep 2025Oct 2025 – Sep 2026
2024Oct–Dec 2024: $380,000 average, 54 sales
2025Jan–Mar 2025: $402,000 average, 29 sales
2025Apr–Jun 2025: $354,000 average, 63 sales
2025Jul–Sep 2025: $359,000 average, 68 sales
2025Oct–Dec 2025: $452,000 average, 43 sales
2026Jan–Mar 2026: $412,000 average, 52 sales
2026Apr–Jun 2026: $369,000 average, 62 sales
2026Jul–Sep 2026: $376,000 average, 76 sales
2024Oct–Dec 2024: 139 days on average, 54 sales
2025Jan–Mar 2025: 170 days on average, 29 sales
2025Apr–Jun 2025: 136 days on average, 63 sales
2025Jul–Sep 2025: 99 days on average, 68 sales
2025Oct–Dec 2025: 143 days on average, 43 sales
2026Jan–Mar 2026: 152 days on average, 52 sales
2026Apr–Jun 2026: 114 days on average, 62 sales
2026Jul–Sep 2026: 109 days on average, 76 sales
See the numbers for each 3-month period
| 3 months | Homes sold | Average sale price | Average days to sell | How close to asking price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct–Dec 2024 | 54 | $380,000 | 139 | 96.5% |
| Jan–Mar 2025 | 29 | $402,000 | 170 | 97.0% |
| Apr–Jun 2025 | 63 | $354,000 | 136 | 96.1% |
| Jul–Sep 2025 | 68 | $359,000 | 99 | 95.5% |
| Oct–Dec 2025 | 43 | $452,000 | 143 | 95.5% |
| Jan–Mar 2026 | 52 | $412,000 | 152 | 94.9% |
| Apr–Jun 2026 | 62 | $369,000 | 114 | 95.5% |
| Jul–Sep 2026 | 76 | $376,000 | 109 | 96.4% |
Source: Flexmls Market Trends, from the White Mountain Association of REALTORS® MLS (the shared database local agents list homes in), homes only (no land), Cities of Heber and Overgaard. Data covers October 2024 through September 2026 and was pulled October 18, 2026. Average sale price means all the sale prices added up and divided by the number of homes sold. Days to sell counts from the day a home was first listed, including any earlier listing of the same home that ended without a sale. How close to asking price compares each sale price with the home’s asking price just before it sold (after any price cuts). Not a valuation of any property.
What the Heber-Overgaard Market Is Doing
Heber-Overgaard is a getaway market. Its cabins are among the closest mountain cabins to the Valley, so weekend demand stays steady from spring through fall. Most sales are cabins and forest-edge homes, and buyers look for usable outdoor space, decks and year-round access.
Land sells steadily here, and one-to-five-acre parcels with power nearby sell well. Seller financing (the seller acts as the lender, often called owner-carry) is common enough that buyers short on cash should not assume they are priced out. My own featured listing at 1740 Eskimo Lane (5 acres with power, septic and 700 gallons of water storage) is a good example of what Rim-country land offers at this price point.
If You Are Buying
- Decide up front whether you want a winterized year-round cabin or a seasonal getaway. It changes your search.
- Check access and snow-plowing on forest-edge roads.
- Ask me about land with seller financing (owner-carry). It is common here.
- Get alerts for new Rim-country listings.
If You Are Selling
- Weekend buyers tour Friday–Sunday, so your cabin should show its best on short notice.
- Highlight what getaway buyers want: decks, fire pits, storage for toys.
- My listings get professional photos, video and drone footage at no cost to you.
- Get an instant valuation of your cabin or land.
A Closer Look at the Heber-Overgaard Market
Heber-Overgaard is one of the more affordable places to own in the White Mountains. Buyers come for space and quiet in the pines along the Mogollon Rim, for weekend cabins and full-time homes, at lower prices than Pinetop-Lakeside. Most of what is for sale here is cabins, site-built and manufactured homes, and larger wooded or acreage parcels for those who want room to spread out or build.
Like the rest of the high country, activity is seasonal, with the most buyers touring in the warmer months. With 152 homes sold in the past 6 months and 138 for sale right now, well-priced cabins and lots still sell. Buyers here pay close attention to access, utilities, wildfire safety (including cleared space around the home), and whether a property is on grid or set up for off-grid living.
Online estimates miss these details. I can walk you through current Heber-Overgaard listings and recent sales so you can judge value.
The newest White Mountains sales numbers and my latest local posts, sent free by email once a month. Unsubscribe anytime.
You will get one email asking you to confirm. Your email is used only for the monthly update.
Want Exact Numbers for Your Street?
Online estimates miss things that matter up here, like wells, septic, acreage, cabins and seller financing. I will pull recent sales of similar homes in your area the same day you ask.
Get My Free ValuationGet New Listing Alerts☎ Better Call Shawn




