☎ (928) 242-3192· Serving the White Mountains since 2015Equal Housing OpportunityShawn Wirtz
Shawn J. WirtzREALTOR® · BETTER CALL SHAWN
White Mountains, Arizona

White Mountains Homes $250,000 – $450,000

The middle of the market: site-built homes, cabins and townhomes in the pines.

LIVE MLS LISTINGS

Homes $250k-$450k: On the Market Now

Updated straight from the MLS. Tap any listing for photos, details and showings.

See all Homes $250k–$450k →

Search Every White Mountains Listing →

The Middle of the Market

The $250,000 to $450,000 range is where most White Mountains buyers land. Expect site-built homes, cabins and townhomes in the region’s most popular towns.

This range has the widest choice of homes for both full-time living and second homes.

Site-Built HomesPlus cabins and townhomes.
Popular TownsShow Low, Pinetop-Lakeside, Heber.
Broad SelectionThe deepest inventory in the market.
Best areas in this range: Show Low, Pinetop-Lakeside, Heber-Overgaard, Snowflake, and Taylor.

What $250K to $450K Buys, Town by Town

Price per square foot is the quickest way to compare towns. Using the median asking price per square foot from my November 2026 market reports, here is roughly how much home $350,000 buys:

  • Snowflake & Taylor (about $225/sq ft): roughly 1,550 sq ft, often newer site-built homes on bigger lots.
  • Concho & Vernon (about $224/sq ft): roughly 1,550 sq ft, frequently with acreage.
  • Heber-Overgaard (about $282/sq ft): roughly 1,250 sq ft of cabin or full-time home in the pines on the Rim.
  • Show Low (about $290/sq ft): roughly 1,200 sq ft, close to the region’s shopping, medical care and jobs.
  • Pinetop-Lakeside (about $305/sq ft): roughly 1,150 sq ft, with tall pines, lakes and trails nearby.

These are medians across all property types and conditions (WMAR MLS, as of Nov 1, 2026), so a specific home can land well above or below. Ask me for a closed-sales comparison on any home you like, or compare towns in the market reports.

What to Check in This Price Range

Shopping a different budget? See homes under $250K or homes from $450K to $700K.

White Mountains Homes $250,000 – $450,000

Browse current listings in this price range, or I can set up alerts for new listings that match what you want.

Browse Listings What’s My Home Worth?