☎ (928) 242-3192· Serving the White Mountains since 2015Equal Housing OpportunityShawn Wirtz
Shawn J. WirtzREALTOR® · BETTER CALL SHAWN
Coconino County · White Mountains, AZ

Forest Lakes Homes & Cabins for Sale

Forest Lakes is a small cabin community on the Mogollon Rim along Highway 260, in tall pines at about 7,600 feet. It stays cool in summer and is close to the Rim lakes and national forest.

Search Listings Better Call Shawn
Forest Lakes AZ real estate

LIVE MLS LISTINGS

Forest Lakes Rim-Country Cabins: On the Market Now

Updated straight from the MLS. Tap any listing for photos, details and showings.

No Results Found.

Search Every White Mountains Listing →

Search Forest Lakes Homes for Sale

Current MLS listings in Forest Lakes are shown above and update automatically. Search every Forest Lakes listing on the map → Prefer a hand-picked list? Get my tailored list →

About Forest Lakes

Set in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest between Payson and Heber, Forest Lakes is a cabin community, with pines, quiet and easy access to the Rim Lakes. Valley families come up for weekends and summers.

The community is heavily wooded and snowy in winter, with cabins and mountain homes on forested lots plus land for those who want to build.

Things to Do & See

  • Woods Canyon Lake: One of Arizona’s most popular Rim lakes, minutes away for trout fishing and paddling.
  • Willow Springs Lake: A nearby lake for fishing and boating, ringed by pines.
  • Mogollon Rim overlooks: Clifftop views along the Rim Road just outside the community.
  • Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest: Trails, forest roads, and wildlife right out the door (the Black Mesa Ranger District in Overgaard manages the surrounding forest).
  • Cool Rim elevation: Summers stay crisp and green while the desert bakes below.

Why Buyers Choose Forest Lakes

  • A cabin community in the pines on the Mogollon Rim
  • Cool summers and snowy winters
  • Minutes from Woods Canyon and Willow Springs Lakes
  • Heavily wooded, private lots
  • A central Rim location between Payson and Heber-Overgaard

Neighborhoods & Communities in Forest Lakes

Forest Lakes sits on the edge of the Mogollon Rim and is named for the lakes around it. Most homes are cabins on wooded lots near the National Forest. A few of the areas I help buyers and sellers with:

  • Forest Lakes Estates: the main subdivision, 975 lots of cabins, timber-frame homes and buildable land among the ponderosas just off Highway 260 (Coconino County counted 904 housing units in Forest Lakes in the 2020 Census).
  • Pilots: the Mogollon Airpark fly-in community people sometimes associate with Forest Lakes is about 20 miles east in Overgaard. See Heber-Overgaard.

Water comes from the Forest Lakes Domestic Water Improvement District’s community system, and each property has its own septic. It’s about 19 road miles to Heber-Overgaard, 36 to Payson and 54 to Show Low. I also work in nearby Heber-Overgaard, Clay Springs & Pinedale, and Show Low.

Services, Water & Governance in Forest Lakes

Forest Lakes has no town government, so a handful of local districts and Coconino County run things. Here’s who does what, from the community’s own governance page and Coconino County’s 2023 community assessment:

  • Coconino County: planning and zoning, building permits, county ordinances and the unpaved county roads. State Route 260 is maintained by the state.
  • Water: the Forest Lakes Domestic Water Improvement District (formed in 1992, with an elected board) runs the community wells, storage tanks, hydrants and meters.
  • Sewer: there is no community sewer. Each property has its own system, mostly alternative (engineered) systems because of clay, rock and groundwater conditions, so a septic inspection matters here.
  • Fire and EMS: the Forest Lakes Fire District provides year-round, 24/7 fire and emergency medical service.
  • Electric and internet: electricity is APS; Verizon and Frontier offer high-speed internet, though connectivity can be limited.
  • Schools: students ride the bus to Heber-Overgaard Unified School District schools.
  • HOA: the Forest Lakes Owners Association is a voluntary community group with no required dues and no power to enforce CC&Rs, so it isn’t an HOA.

One thing every buyer should know: the USDA Forest Service’s Wildfire Risk to Communities tool rates Forest Lakes’ wildfire risk as “Very High,” and the community keeps a Firewise action plan. Read my wildfire insurance & defensible space guide and get an insurance quote early.

Sources: Forest Lakes governance; Coconino County Community Assessment Report for Forest Lakes (Nov. 2023).

Shawn’s Local Favorite

Get up early and be at Woods Canyon Lake before the crowds. With mist on the water and pines all around, it is a good way to start the day, and the lake is right around the corner from Forest Lakes.

Market snapshot · November 2026

Forest Lakes home sales right now

Few Forest Lakes homes sell through the White Mountain MLS (one closed sale in the 12 months to Oct 2, 2026), so I don't publish a typical price here; most Forest Lakes sales are listed on other MLS systems. Ask me for a custom sales report.

Living here

Forest Lakes costs & services

CountyCoconino County
Property taxesThe Census doesn’t publish a reliable median for a community this small. A primary residence gets Arizona’s homeowner rebate on part of the primary property tax (up to $600 a parcel), so the same house as a second home or rental usually pays more. Check any parcel’s actual bill: Coconino County Assessor parcel search.
InternetCheck providers and speeds for an exact address on the FCC National Broadband Map.
ElectricAPS (Arizona Public Service).
Water & septicVaries by parcel: town or private water company in some areas, private or shared wells or hauled water in others, and septic outside sewer areas. See my wells, septic & utilities guide.
SchoolsChevelon Butte School District (Forest Lakes students attend Heber-Overgaard Unified schools). Boundaries can vary by address, so confirm with the district.
Nearest hospitalBanner Payson Medical Center (Payson), about 38 road miles
Phoenix Sky Harbor AirportAbout 121 road miles

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates (shown for communities of 1,000+ people); Census school district boundaries; electric utility service areas (Navopache Electric Cooperative and APS); road miles from OpenStreetMap routing from the town center. Checked October 2026.

Forest Lakes Real Estate FAQs

Where is Forest Lakes?

Forest Lakes is a small cabin community in Coconino County, right on the Mogollon Rim along Highway 260 between Payson and Heber-Overgaard.

What kinds of properties are available?

Mostly cabins and mountain homes on wooded lots, plus land to build on. Given the community’s small size, inventory is limited and good cabins move quickly.

What lakes are nearby?

Woods Canyon Lake and Willow Springs Lake, two of the most popular Rim lakes, are just minutes away for fishing and paddling.

Does Forest Lakes have city water or wells?

Most homes are on the community water system run by the Forest Lakes Domestic Water Improvement District, which operates several wells, storage tanks and fire hydrants. There’s no community sewer, so every property has its own septic system.

Does Forest Lakes have an HOA?

Not in the usual sense. The Forest Lakes Owners Association is voluntary, has no required dues and doesn’t enforce CC&Rs. Zoning and building are handled by Coconino County, so check county rules and any recorded subdivision restrictions for a specific lot.

What is the weather like?

At about 7,600 feet, summers are cool and green and winters are snowy.

What My Clients Say

Real reviews from my clients on Zillow and Google, word for word.

★★★★★
“Shawn was extremely helpful and responsive. Made this selling process simple and easy. He handled everything from start to finish. Highly recommend!!”
Scott F.Sold a property · Sep 2026 · Google
★★★★★
“Two times Shawn was our agent. Top notch professional. Highly recommend”
Tracey W.Repeat client · Jun 2025 · Google
★★★★★
“The best thing about Shawn is he always answers texts, phone calls and emails. He is flexible with our schedule. We would use Shawn again.”
Lanae B.Jun 2024 · Google

Read all reviews →

Latest Local News & Guides

Recent posts from my blog on what’s changing around the White Mountains.

See all posts →

Your Forest Lakes Realtor: Recently Sold Nearby by Shawn Wirtz

I’m Shawn Wirtz, a REALTOR® with Advantage Realty Professionals in Lakeside, and I’ve closed 398 sales across the White Mountains since 2015, including nearby Heber and Overgaard. Here are a few of those sales.

More Heber-Overgaard Sales

Represented by Shawn J. Wirtz · Advantage Realty Professionals

  • 2815 Pine Hill Drive Overgaard$312,500
  • 2852 Timber Trail Loop Overgaard$270,000
  • 1979 Doe Circle Heber$207,000
  • 3486 Quail Run Road Overgaard$180,000
  • 2130 Cottontail Road Overgaard$130,000
  • 2703 Rustlers Roost Overgaard$123,000
Better Call Shawn - Shawn Wirtz, White Mountains REALTOR

Thinking of selling in Forest Lakes?

I’ve closed 398 White Mountains property sales since 2015, including nearby Heber and Overgaard. If you’re thinking about selling a Forest Lakes cabin, call me.

Advantage Realty ProfessionalsMLS and Equal Housing Opportunity