At our elevation, heat is one of the biggest costs of owning a home, and when you look at houses up here, how a place is heated matters as much as the square footage. Homes in Show Low, Pinetop-Lakeside and the surrounding towns heat with propane, electricity or a mix of the two, often with a wood stove on the side. I ran the numbers on what a unit of heat costs with each one, using 2026 utility rates and recent propane prices.
Why our heating bills run high
Heating degree days measure how cold a place is over a season. Show Low’s airport averages about 4,926 a year, and roughly 2,609 of those fall in December, January and February alone, according to NOAA’s 1991-2020 climate normals. Average December lows are about 23°F. A house here spends a lot of the year with the furnace running.
What electricity costs
Show Low is split between two electric providers, and Pinetop-Lakeside is too, so check which one serves a home before you compare bills.
- Navopache Electric Cooperative: a $36 monthly service charge, then 7.835¢ per kWh for the first 400 kWh and 11.885¢ per kWh above that, under the standard residential rate that took effect Jan. 1, 2026. A purchased-power adjustment and a few small adders can move the final number.
- APS: on the Fixed Energy Charge plan (R-1), energy runs 12.925¢ per kWh for homes averaging 600 kWh or less a month and up to 15.418¢ for homes averaging 1,000 kWh or more, before adjustors and taxes. APS has a rate case pending, and the Arizona Corporation Commission has to vote by Dec. 31, 2026, so expect new APS rates in early 2027.
What propane costs
This one’s harder to pin down. The federal government’s weekly propane survey doesn’t cover Arizona. The closest published number is the Rocky Mountain region, which averaged $2.248 a gallon for residential propane the week of Oct. 5, 2026, against $2.598 nationally, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Those prices leave out taxes. Your actual price depends on your supplier, how much you buy and whether you own the tank, so get a current quote.
Comparing them on the same scale
A gallon of propane holds about 91,452 Btu and a kWh holds 3,412 Btu (EIA conversion factors). Adjusting for how efficiently each system turns fuel into heat, this is roughly what one million Btu of delivered heat costs:
- Propane, 95% efficient furnace, at $2.25/gal: about $25.90
- Propane, 80% efficient furnace, at $2.25/gal: about $30.75
- Electric baseboard or furnace, Navopache upper tier: about $34.83
- Electric baseboard or furnace, APS top R-1 tier: about $45.19
- Heat pump, Navopache upper tier: about $19.90
- Heat pump, APS top R-1 tier: about $25.82
For heat pumps I assumed an efficiency of 1.75, which is the minimum the cold-climate heat pump specification requires at 5°F. Over a whole winter a good cold-climate unit should do better than that, and an older standard heat pump may do worse in a deep cold snap. These are my calculations from the published rates, not utility quotes.
An example winter
Say a home burns 500 gallons of propane in a 95% furnace over a winter. That’s about 43.4 million Btu of heat. At $2.25 a gallon, the propane costs about $1,125. Getting the same heat from electric resistance on Navopache’s upper tier would cost about $1,513, or about $1,963 on APS’s top R-1 tier. A heat pump at the 1.75 efficiency above would cost about $865 on Navopache or $1,122 on APS. Your home’s usage will be different, and propane at your supplier’s price could move these numbers either way.
Rebates in 2026
The federal energy-efficient home improvement credit ended for equipment placed in service after Dec. 31, 2025, according to the IRS. APS says its AC, smart thermostat and home-checkup rebates are no longer available as of Jan. 1, 2026, and I didn’t find a heat pump rebate on Navopache’s site. Check with your utility before you buy equipment, since programs change.
What to ask before you buy a home
- Twelve months of electric and propane bills, so you see a real winter.
- Whether the propane tank is owned or leased, its size, and who fills it.
- The age and efficiency rating of the furnace, or the model of the heat pump.
- Which electric provider serves the address.
- Whether there’s a wood or pellet stove for backup when the power goes out.
My fall checklist for mountain homeowners covers getting the heat ready once you’re in.
A heat pump only helps if it’s sized and rated for cold climates. If a listing says “heat pump,” ask for the model number and look it up. If you’re on Navopache, also ask about the winter time-of-use rate, which is much cheaper outside peak hours.
Frequently asked questions
Is propane or electric heat cheaper in Show Low?
With 2026 rates and propane near $2.25 a gallon, an efficient propane furnace costs less per unit of heat than electric baseboard, while a cold-climate heat pump can cost less than either. Your propane price and electric provider make the difference.
Who provides electricity in Show Low and Pinetop-Lakeside?
Both APS and Navopache Electric Cooperative serve parts of Show Low and Pinetop-Lakeside. Check a recent bill or ask the seller which one serves the home.
Are there heat pump rebates in Arizona in 2026?
The federal home improvement tax credit ended after 2025, and APS ended its residential rebates on Jan. 1, 2026. Check with your utility for anything new before you buy.
Comparing homes this winter?
I can help you get heating and utility details on any home before you write an offer.
Get Listing AlertsBetter Call Shawn


Header photo © Childress Nature Photography.








