Curious what your Show Low home could sell for this fall? You can see a free estimate in seconds, and below are the local sales numbers every good price starts from.

How to Get Your Number
- See an instant estimate. Enter your address on my home value page. You get an automated value range on screen right away, built on current 2026 White Mountains sales. No email required to see it.
- Get a closer number. An automated range is a starting point. If you want a real value range, I look at similar homes that sold near you and what is competing with you right now, then send you the range.
- Talk it through. Better Call Shawn at (928) 242-3192. No pressure, no obligation.
What Show Low Homes Are Selling For
Show Low homes sold in the past 90 days, as of Nov 1, 2026. “Typical” is the middle number: half sold for more and half for less. % of asking: Oct 2025–Sep 2026.
Right now Show Low homes for sale have a typical asking price of $425,000, while the typical home that sold went for $385,000. Homes sold for about 96% of their final asking price, or roughly 4% under. That gap is the most important thing to understand when you set a price: homes priced in line with recent sales sell, and homes priced above them tend to sit.
Price per Square Foot Across the White Mountains
Price per square foot is a quick way to sanity-check any estimate. Here is how Show Low compares with nearby areas.
| Area | Price per sq. ft. | Typical sold price | Median days to sell | Time period |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Greer | $328 | $446,500 | 88 | 6 months |
| Alpine-Nutrioso | $315 | $406,500 | 67 | 6 months |
| White Mountain Lake | $293 | $180,500 | 84 | 6 months |
| Show Low | $288 | $385,000 | 85 | 90 days |
| Heber-Overgaard | $284 | $365,500 | 85 | 6 months |
| Pinetop-Lakeside | $278 | $465,000 | 90 | 90 days |
| Linden | $251 | $480,000 | 95 | 6 months |
| Clay Springs-Pinedale | $242 | $390,000 | 87 | 12 months |
| Concho-Vernon | $238 | $319,500 | 109 | 6 months |
| Snowflake | $206 | $355,000 | 97 | 6 months |
| Springerville-Eagar | $190 | $275,000 | 69 | 6 months |
| Taylor | $170 | $350,000 | 84 | 6 months |
| St. Johns | $122 | $219,400 | 121 | 6 months |
As of Nov 1, 2026, over the time period shown for each area. Smaller areas use 6 or 12 months so there are enough sales to be meaningful.
What Moves a Home’s Value in Show Low
- Recent sales nearby. Pricing against what similar homes sold for recently, not last year’s peak, is what gets a home sold.
- Price range. The $300K–$450K range is selling best right now.
- Location and condition. Well-priced, move-in-ready homes and homes near Fool Hollow Lake, Show Low Lake or the bluff are usually the most competitive.
- Timing. Buyers touring this fall are serious. Pricing right before winter matters, because sales slow down from December through February.
Better Call Shawn: (928) 242-3192
See your free estimate now, or read the full Show Low market report.
Get My Free Home ValueShow Low Market ReportSearch Show Low HomesSources: White Mountain Association of REALTORS® MLS via Flexmls. Sold homes: past 90 days as of Nov 1, 2026. Homes for sale: as of Nov 1, 2026. % of asking: Flexmls Market Trends, Oct 2025–Sep 2026. Area table: as of Nov 1, 2026, over the time period shown. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Not a valuation or appraisal of any property. Shawn J. Wirtz, REALTOR®, Advantage Realty Professionals, Lakeside, AZ. Equal Housing Opportunity.











